At the height of the fighting on 8th May 1915 during the Second Battle of Ypres, the battalion headquarters of the 1st Monmouths became cut off from the troops of the battalion who were facing strong German attacks. In order to gain some measure of control over events the officers of the headquarters moved forward to the front line. As a consequence, the battalion Commander, Colonel Charles Robinson, and the second in command, Major Edward Williams, were both soon killed. Another officer who moved forward with the headquarters was Captain Edward Charles Dimsdale, the adjutant with responsibility for battalion administration. Faced with attacks from their front and from their right flank, where adjoining British troops had withdrawn, the situation of the Monmouths was desperate. A particular problem was a German machine gun, located in a farm. Captain Dimsdale attempted to organise an attack on the farm with the aim of silencing the machine gun. Rifleman David John Jones of B Company wrote to Mr F Morgan at the locomotive shed on Alexandra Dock Newport and described the event:
“I am sorry to have to write to you, as it is bad news I am sending. Harry is reported missing, and so is young Alf Baker. You would be able to break the news to Harry’s wife and mother; that is why I am writing to you. How it happened was this. The brigade which was supposed to relieve us failed to come up in time last Thursday. As we were in support we had to go back to the trenches. We went back on Thursday night and carried up trench stores. Early on Friday morning we went into the first line dug-outs. We stayed there all day and at night took our place in the trenches. Half had to go in the firing trench while the other half went into the reserves trenches, which were about 20 yards behind. Harry, Alf. Baker, Jack Lawrence and myself were in the same trench. Just after daylight the Germans opened a very heavy fire on us which lasted all the morning. The shelling was awful and they blew in every parapet along the trenches. We first realised that the position was serious about noon when the order came, ‘All support into the firing trench.’ Just as we started the Adjutant came and said, ‘About turn; the Germans are charging. They have got the farm on the right. Who’ll volunteer for a charge and drive them back?’ Harry, Jack Lawrence, Alf. Baker and myself at once sprang forward with fixed bayonets together with all the platoon. When the adjutant saw the response he said, ‘That’s right boys, come on.’ Just then he fell dead. But we kept on and when we came to the barn we made the charge. We were outnumbered by great odds. As the regiment we were supporting had been gassed, they could do nothing. We had to retire again and when we got back to the trenches I started looking for the boys, but couldn’t find them anywhere. I started making inquiries, and someone said they had seen Jack Lawrence lying in a trench dying, with five wounds. I couldn’t find any trace of Harry or Alf anywhere. Bob Brown was killed and Jim Stuart is missing, we still retained some hope for their welfare. When we retired we got mixed up with some other regiments. Jim Crump and some others were missing but they returned to camp yesterday. He had been with another regiment. When we got back to the trenches, we held on with the pluck which always characterises a British soldier. We suffered heavily but the Germans have suffered more so. As last when there was only a handful of us left and the Germans were coming on again, we had to retire a little way back, as the heavy firing which was going on stopped re-inforcements reaching us. We got the trenches back at the bayonet point. We have now been relieved after nearly a month of trenches and supports and are on the way back for a rest. Jack Hughes is in the hospital.”
Harry and Bob Brown were killed on that day. Rifleman Robert William Brown was aged 28 and Rifleman Harry Flook was aged 34; neither of these men has a known grave and both are commemorated on the Menin Gate. Bob Brown was the husband of Melinda and lived at 22 Robert Street. He was the son of Charles J Brown, a rigger and dock pilot, and Rosina Brown. In 1901 Bob also had 3 brothers; Chas aged 17, a mason’s labourer, George and Albert. Harry was the son of Harry Flook of ‘Glan Tawe’, Queens Hill, Newport and the husband of Georgina aged 33 who lived at 7 Prince Street Maindee. The 1901 Census shows a newly wed Harry aged 21 living with his wife and 3 month old daughter Elizabeth at 40 Wharf Road; he was working as a Fruiterer’s Assistant.
“Young Alf Baker,” was Rifleman Alfred Baker, who had not been killed, but had been taken prisoner. He survived the war and was discharged from the army in February 1919. At the time of writing, his exact identity is unknown, but it is likely that he was Alfred Christopher Baker, born in 1895 and the son of Edward Baker, a docks foreman, and Mary Baker of Price Street. Jack Lawrence, Rifleman John Lawrence was not dying, but survived his wounds and was discharged from the army in January 1919. Jack was the son of William Lawrence, a hatter and hosier, of High Street and Annie Lawrence.
Captain Edward Charles Dimsdale was attached to the 1st Monmouths from the Rifle Brigade. He was 31 and the son of Charles, The Seventh Baron Dimsdale, of Meesden Manor, Hertfordshire. He has no known grave and is commemorated on the Menin Gate. Within a year his younger brother, Lieutenant Reginald Thomas Dimsdale was also killed while serving as commander of submarine E22. On 25 April 1916 the submarine was torpedoed in the North Sea by German U Boat UB18 commanded by the German U Boat ace Otto Steinbrinck.
Rifleman James Henry Stewart was killed on 8th May; he has no known grave and is commemorated on the Menin Gate. Rifleman James William Crump survived 8th May and became a sergeant, though he did not survive the war. He was killed aged 25 at the Battle of Loos on 13th October 1915 during the 1st Monmouths involvement in an attack on the German Hohenzollern Redoubt; he has no known grave and is commemorated on the Loos Memorial.
Finally the author of the letter, Rifleman David Jones did survive the war. He was promoted to sergeant, but was discharged from the army in August 1916.
Guided Battlefield Tours organise fully guided tours to Ypres, see: www.guidedbattlefieldtours.co.uk